Our HOA sent a violations letter for loud and raucous behavior occurring during the mid-night hours. Three homeowners signed a statement that they witnessed the behavior. The served homeowner requested an appeal hearing which the HOA will arrange and honor. Is it mandatory for the witnesses to appear at the appeals meeting? This presents a setup for potential retaliation by the homeowner that was served and/or any personal supporters. We want to keep the names of the three witnesses confidential, as well as not requiring their presence at the appeal meeting. As a board member, I believe in protecting the homeowners from the wrath of the served homeowner. This is an appeal, not a judge and jury situation. Your comments and similar experiences welcomed.